Of all the game reviewers out there, only one continually earns my respect and actually holds any sway over my purchase of a game. Yahtzee, that irritable British-turned-Aussie curmudgeon from Zero Punctuation, almost always seems to echo my thoughts on games we've both played, and can usually predict exactly how I'm going to feel on games I haven't. Never before have I found a video game reviewer that feels exactly how I do, with his utter loathing for multiplayer and JRPGs, and his ability to see through the bullshit and call the games on it. We like a lot of the same games, and we hate a lot of the same games. I nearly wept with vindication when he spoke the words "Even if we concede to the fanboys that a Zelda game can only be judged alongside other Zelda games, Skyward Sword is the worst Zelda game I've ever played."
Though, I've noticed that whenever we disagree on a game, we disagree hugely.